For German Firms, Ties to Russia Are Personal, Not Just Financial


BERLIN — When Peter Fenkl heard that Russia had invaded Ukraine, he mentioned his first ideas weren’t for the enterprise his German firm stood to lose in both nation, however for the fates of his workers within the area, who over years of enterprise dealings and shared drinks had change into extra than simply colleagues.

“These are extra than simply enterprise relationships, they’re actual friendships,” mentioned Mr. Fenkl, the chief government of the corporate, a maker of commercial followers. “We’ve got sat subsequent to one another in conferences, had beers collectively.”

The family-owned firm, Ziehl-Abegg, has 4,300 workers, and Mr. Fenkl recalled how the groups from Germany, Russia and Ukraine labored side-by-side, on enterprise journeys and through commerce gala’s the place Ziehl-Abegg would show its wares.

Now all 4 of the corporate’s workers in Ukraine have taken up arms to defend their nation. In Russia, the place the corporate has a manufacturing facility and employs 30 individuals, enterprise has floor to a halt.

Mr. Fenkl mentioned he had spoken a number of instances together with his firm’s supervisor in Russia prior to now week, attempting to determine tips on how to proceed because the gravity of the scenario turned clearer.

“Twice I referred to as the colleague in Russia and he couldn’t speak,” Mr. Fenkl added. “He saved breaking down in tears.”

German corporations do way more enterprise in Russia than some other European Union nation does, exporting items price greater than 26 billion euros ($28.4 billion) final 12 months (Poland was second with €8 billion) and investing an extra €25 billion in operations there. This dedication to the Russian financial system displays, partly, an ethos embraced by the previous West Germany popping out of World Battle II — that commerce may guarantee peace and forestall Europe from descending into one other conflict.

Russia’s annexation of Crimea in 2014, and the sanctions that adopted, prompted the variety of German corporations investing in Russia to drop by a 3rd. Nonetheless, the determine was slightly below 4,000 corporations by 2020, with many satisfied that their presence may assist anchor Russia within the democratic sphere.

On Feb. 24, that perception was shattered, leaving corporations of all sizes questioning what to do subsequent.

Whereas some have introduced choices to drag out and have began unwinding enterprise ties, others are attempting to remain on, some out of loyalty to their workers, regardless of Western sanctions which have thrown up large obstacles to banking and cross-border transport, and the collapse of the ruble. What stays for a lot of companies is a profound sense of unhappiness, coupled with disillusionment.

Germany’s main automakers — BMW, Volkswagen, Mercedes-Benz and Daimler Truck — all introduced final week that they have been halting their exports and manufacturing in Russia. Household-owned corporations, together with ZF Group, a automotive components maker, and Haniel, which manages a number of unbiased companies within the nation, are doing the identical.

“Whereas our choices are restricted, we nonetheless can have an effect,” Thomas Schmidt, chief government of Haniel, mentioned in a video assertion, asserting that each one enterprise actions in Russia and Belarus can be halted and commitments unwound. “I perceive it’s robust from a buyer and provider relationship perspective, however it’s extra necessary that we get individuals on the road protesting.”

That sentiment is even coming from the German Japanese Enterprise Affiliation, a gaggle of corporations that for many years has been a cheerleader for deeper financial ties with Moscow, even within the face of the more and more anti-democratic strikes by President Vladimir V. Putin. The group is celebrating its seventieth anniversary this 12 months, and a number of other of its members have been beforehand scheduled to fulfill final week with the Russian president in Moscow. The journey was deserted after the invasion.

“We should always name a spade a spade: It’s at present much less in regards to the sanctions and their penalties than in regards to the query of whether or not or not we’ll nonetheless have important financial relations with Russia sooner or later,” mentioned Oliver Hermes, chairman of the enterprise group. In 2014, the group had campaigned towards extreme financial punishment for Moscow, however this time is completely different.

“The earlier the Russian authorities stops this conflict, the extra of those relations can nonetheless be saved,” Mr. Hermes mentioned. “There isn’t any query that the German financial system will help the sanctions imposed.”

Years in the past Martin Daller, the chief government of Seebacher, a maker of specialty lighting controls, hadn’t been keen on investing in Russia. Nevertheless it is a gigantic, engaging marketplace for the merchandise developed by his family-owned firm, primarily based in Unhealthy-Tölz, and when a Russian supervisor stop a rival firm and approached him about establishing a Russian division, he determined to provide it a attempt.

That was simply earlier than the outbreak of the coronavirus pandemic, however enterprise was beginning to choose up this 12 months. Then got here the invasion.

“Now, we’re questioning what we should always do. Break off contact and simply let him go,” mentioned Mr. Daller, whose firm has annual income of €2.5 million. “From a monetary viewpoint, it wouldn’t be that dramatic for us. However he’s a father of three and the entire household is determined by his job.”

It’s not solely the smaller corporations which might be dealing with robust choices.

Wintershall Dea, a German oil and gasoline firm with a world portfolio of tasks, canceled its annual firm information convention that was to be held on Feb. 25, the day after the invasion. As a substitute, its leaders issued a joint assertion on March 2 expressing alarm on the conflict.

“We’ve got been working in Russia for over 30 years. Lots of our colleagues at our different areas additionally work with companions from Russia each day,” it learn. “We’ve got constructed many private relationships — together with in our joint ventures with Gazprom,” Russia’s state power big.

“However the Russian conflict of aggression towards Ukraine marks a turning level,” they mentioned. “What is occurring now’s shaking the very foundations of our cooperation.”

The corporate individually mentioned that it could cease funds to Russia and write off its €1 billion funding within the ill-fated Nord Stream 2 pure gasoline pipeline linking Russia and Germany, that the federal government in Berlin had suspended on Feb. 22. It would additionally not obtain any income from its oil and gasoline operations in Russia, which accounted for almost a fifth of its working revenue in 2021.

Not each German firm is pulling out. Metro, a wholesale meals firm with 93 areas in Russia, the place it had income of €2.4 billion final 12 months, mentioned that it had determined to proceed operations out of concern that pulling out would disrupt meals provides to the inhabitants. “None of our 10,000 workers in Russia is personally answerable for the conflict in Ukraine,” the corporate mentioned in an announcement.

Metro mentioned it was additionally attempting to function a few of its 26 shops in Ukraine, relying on the safety scenario, and was supporting efforts to supply for individuals who have been pressured to flee their properties.

Past the impression to corporations that had invested in Russia, analysts are predicting that the broader German financial system will likely be damage by will increase in costs for power and meals on account of the conflict. For the reason that invasion, politicians have been rallying the general public to view their sacrifices via a wider lens.

“My nation, Germany, would be the nation that may bear the brunt of the sanctions which were adopted by the European Union and by the U.S.,” Emily Haber, Germany’s ambassador to america, said on Twitter. “We’re ready to hold the burden. Freedom is priceless.”


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here